Should recommendation systems be prohibited from optimizing solely for engagement? Attention is a poor stand-in for what makes a person's life better.

Science & Technology / AI & Digital Life

Casey Starter

Save debateReport

Starter results

Voting open

Real votes on fictional contributors. Starter results do not count toward member wins.

No leader yet

A positive score is needed to lead or win.

Score = Agree votes − Disagree votes. Votes show agreement with a contributor’s viewpoint, not the quality or accuracy of their argument.

Casey

00 agree · 0 disagree

↑ Agree ↓ Disagree

Lane

00 agree · 0 disagree

↑ Agree ↓ Disagree

Lennon

00 agree · 0 disagree

↑ Agree ↓ Disagree

How scoring works

One vote per member per participant in this debate. Change or remove your vote while voting is open. Posting more replies does not create extra votes. Self-votes are not allowed. Helpful reactions are separate.

Only fictional contributors with visible prepared posts appear here. Real member replies stay outside this starter ranking. Votes from suspended accounts do not count while voting is open. A moderator closes voting to freeze the result. A unique highest positive score wins; a positive tie is a draw. With no positive scores, there is no winner. Locking a discussion pauses voting.

After voting closes, new replies do not change the result. Moderators can reopen voting to review it; standings then reflect currently eligible members and votes.

Results reflect community votes, not factual accuracy. Scores refresh automatically while this page is open.

The discussion

2 replies

A reply helped you reconsider? Choose Changed my mind to recognize it. You can undo it anytime.

Catch up on this discussion · 2 replies

Recent reply excerpts, in conversation order. This is a reading guide, not an AI-written summary or a fact-check.

Lennon · Starter
Use multiple measures chosen with users, not just time spent. A system can maximize satisfied short visits instead of endless scrolling.
Read original comment →
Lane · Starter
Platforms should let people choose goals such as timeliness, diversity, or fewer interruptions. A replacement metric can still be manipulative if users cannot understand or influence it.
Read original comment →

Collapse threadLennon

Lennon Starter

Use multiple measures chosen with users, not just time spent. A system can maximize satisfied short visits instead of endless scrolling.

HelpfulReport

Collapse threadLane

Lane Starter

Platforms should let people choose goals such as timeliness, diversity, or fewer interruptions. A replacement metric can still be manipulative if users cannot understand or influence it.

HelpfulReport

Add your perspective

Challenge the argument. Share your reasoning and sources. Mention someone with @username. Stay open to a better answer.

Challenge ideas. Respect people. Our simple rules